Creative Baby Tidy Review: The Best Value Diaper Pail For Containing Stink

I rated Creative Baby TD as my top pick as part of my official review of the best diaper pails for disposable diapers . Read my in-depth review of this beautiful, easy-to-use diaper pail below.

When buying a diaper pail, it's best to prioritize its ability to mask and smell, but you should also consider ease of use, size, capacity, baby safety, and easy cleaning. Creative Baby Tidy reviews several of these boxes and is $20 to $40 cheaper than the Ubbi Top diaper pail set, depending on your choice of pail color. When The Creative Baby goes on sale, it will be almost half the price of Ubbi. All these features combine to make the Creative Baby Tidy my top pick for the best budget diaper pail.

According to Patty Wu, executive vice president and head of brand at ByBuy Baby, you should expect to pay anywhere from $30 to $130 for a diaper pail, making the Creative Baby TD a steal at $50. Besides being reasonably priced, it has a clever design that carries the fragrance without the use of expensive fragrance refills. It's easy to use, inherently resilient for babies and toddlers, and its small size means it fits easily in most nurseries.

Seamless design effectively prevents odors

Creative Baby TD is a smart choice for those looking for an effective odor-fighting diaper pail at a great price. To tell this story, I tested seven of the best diaper pails on the market today and did a lot more research. Of all the pails I tested, Creative Baby has one of the most innovative odor control designs; The rotating cap activates the piston system and pushes soiled cloths into the bucket's main waste compartment. This heavy-duty pestle does double duty: not only does it help remove layers of dirt, it also creates a secure seal so odors can't escape.

Because odor is a major concern for most people when purchasing a diaper pail, I evaluated Creative Baby TD's ability to prevent odor using multiple measurements. I evaluated the Creative Baby Tidy's performance at critical reaction points when I loaded a dirty diaper pail, when I grabbed a bag of diapers from the trash, and when I walked past the diaper pail in my baby's room. The holder was then rated based on his performance on a 10-point Likert scale (10 being the best performance and 0 being the worst). This has happened to all diaper pail competitors. The Creative Baby TD scores well in each of these tests.

It's easy to toss a dirty diaper into the bin with one hand, then use the same hand to close the lid and catch the dirt in the bin underneath. During the 48-hour test period, I barely noticed any odors when loading my baby's diaper pail. On the second day of testing, I noticed a slight smell when I leaned close to the earbuds. The same was true when I walked with the bucket or played nearby in my baby's nursery. Generally though, it keeps odors from penetrating and I left this bucket in my child's room after testing it.

The best thing about owning this diaper pail is the diaper bag. To open Creative Baby, press the button and lift a lever. Then you enter the main waste compartment, remove the diaper bag and load a new waste bag from the pacifier loop into the bucket. When you make this switch, the wide waste chamber releases any odors that have been trapped inside since the bucket was last opened. On the second day of testing the Yak Creative Baby, I discovered a handy trick: when you lift the lever to access the waste compartment, hold Underneath the pacifier loop of taking out the dirty diaper bag, which means the process still stinks (pun intended), it stinks less than sticking your nose straight into an open diaper bag.

The children's room is easy to use and assemble

My favorite aspect of Creative Baby TD is its simplicity and ease of use. There are no covers to open or remove. You never have to worry about your hands accidentally getting stuck in the poop bag. To pour a diaper, simply drop it onto the bucket and pull the handle to twist the lid. Then the piston pushes the diaper into the bucket. Not only is the bucket design easy to use with one hand, but it's also inherently childproof. My 2 year old never had to worry about getting into the bucket when we played in her room. In fact, Creative Baby TD is so easy to use that I sometimes let my baby throw his diaper (#1 only) – a responsibility I thoroughly enjoy!

The Creative Baby TD is compact and slides easily into the corner of the bedroom or nursery. It is just under 2 feet tall, 11 inches wide and 15 inches deep. The curved shape makes it easy to slide under shelves or bookcases. However, you need a little more space to run this bulldozer than some I've tested (like the Ubibi). The rotating lid takes up a few inches of space on either side of the bucket, and I found myself pulling the Creative Baby TD off the nursery wall to empty its contents.

It has the smallest capacity of any diaper pail I've tested, fitting just 10 toddler diapers and 20 newborn diapers at a time. As a result, I change the throw bag of my fancy diaper two to three times a week. As a mom, I'm usually okay with this because it means getting those smelly diapers out of my room. This is something to consider if you prefer a lower spoon change.

No expensive garbage bags or parcels to buy

Diapers can be expensive, especially when you consider the cost of special trash bags and air freshener additives like popular baking soda wrap. The beauty of the Creative Baby Tidy is that it works with standard kitchen bags and doesn't include an air freshener. This is not only practical for cost reasons, but also a plus for those who are sensitive to smells.

Remember, you are more likely to change your creative child's bin than other buckets. Even in childhood, when babies used fewer diapers per day, I had to change the bags in this bucket 2-3 times a week. (Most negative customer reviews about the detergent focus on the plunger getting stuck when the pail is full of diapers). Two to three bags a week can add up, although standard kitchen bags cost less than most brands of diaper pail refills.

my knowledge

I'm a freelance journalist who enjoys reading and writing about the latest products, especially in the outdoor, lifestyle and parenting sectors. I have over seven years of experience working in-house with brands and as a writer, editor and content strategist at leading publications. I currently write for publications such as The Ness Well, Avocado Magazine and UltraSignup . In my career I have written and overseen the production of hundreds of tool guides and product reviews. I am a mother of a 2 year old (about 12) with a baby on the way. I have changed thousands of diapers and will change many more.

While covering this story, I spoke with experts on household products like diaper pails, including Mike Hahn, an industrial designer with experience in the plumbing industry. Patty Wu, executive vice president and president of BuyBuyBaby Brands; Samara Geller, Senior Director of Cleaning Sciences, and Sidney Swanson, Analyst for Healthy Life Sciences, both members of the Environmental Working Group. I also met Wendy Powell, owner of Seattle children's resale shop Childish Things.

How do you compare to other diaper pails?

The Creative Tidy baby diaper pail stands out from the competition with its effective odor control and ease of use. During the 48-hour test period, I got to smell the scents in the bucket while loading diapers and spending time with my baby in his room. Taking a bag of soiled diapers out of the pail is a smelly process, but I found that I could avoid exposing my nose to an open bag of used diapers by wearing the garbage bag under the pacifier loop in the compartment. Waste Bucket – A handy trick that reduces the smell of this job.

If you're looking for a true odor-blocking machine, our top-of-the-line diaper pail, the Ubbi, locks in odors more effectively than Creative Baby. The steel bowl means it can resist odor build-up over time, making it a logical choice for carers who plan to keep the bucket for a while. However, the Creative Baby costs about $30 less than the Ubbi and doesn't require more expensive refill bags than other buckets, making it a good choice for individuals and families interested in keeping costs down.

Like The Creative Baby, the Munchkin Step, another pail winner, is easy to use with one hand and scored top marks in our best diaper pail test. However, this requires refilling the brand's signature pouches, and a puck of scented air freshener is used to mask unpleasant odors. Creative Baby TD might be for you if you're looking for a one-handed diaper pail and prefer unscented products.

How I tested the best diaper pails

Our most effective nappy repellents include scents like the benefits. They are easy to use, easy to clean and suit most seating areas. As an added bonus, they may also have a design or mechanism to prevent little hands from slipping off. Various scales were used throughout the 48-hour experiment to assess these characteristics of the creative child. I loaded the bucket with about 10 smelly diapers at the end of the test window.

Several experiments were conducted to better understand how Creative Baby TD prevents odors. So I took detailed notes on my ability to contain odors at critical times of the day, including putting in my diaper, taking a bag of dirty diapers out of the tub, going to the pail, or time in my baby's room to spend. I translated these observations into a series of ratings based on a 10-point Likert scale

Using a diaper pail is less of a hassle than using a trash can that you can hide under the kitchen sink and have to keep out nasty smells. Therefore, I also collected data on the usability of each of the tested diaper brakes. I evaluated the mechanics of the Creative Baby by opening and closing its various levers and twisting the lid about 100 times. I also took notes on features of the diaper pail, such as construction, size and capacity, rated the baby's safety, and cleaned the pail.

Diaper Belle Obi vs Diaper Genius